In Germany, families of Turkish origin seeking daycare places for their children receive fewer responses and fewer concrete offers solely because of their surnames. A joint study by the Munich-based ifo Institute, the Technical University of Munich (TUM), the Leibniz Institute for Economic Research in Halle (IWH) and the German Centre for Higher Education Research and Science Studies (DZHW) was made public on November 12.
In March 2021, the researchers sent emails on behalf of fictitious parents to more than 22,000 daycare centers that offered places for children under the age of 3. The text of the approximately 18,700 emails that reached their recipients was identical; the sender’s name was randomly selected to be either German or Turkish. This made it possible to determine whether differences in the responses stemmed directly from the name.
Fewer responses and fewer offers
According to the results, 70.7% of applications with German surnames received a response, compared with 66.3% of those with Turkish surnames. Parents with Turkish surnames were about 20% less likely to receive a specific daycare place offer. The responses sent to these families were also shorter and less helpful. Trained assistants who did not know the parents’ names evaluated more than 12,000 responses.

One notable finding of the study concerned education levels. Parents with Turkish surnames who stated in their email signature that they had graduated from university also received fewer responses than those with German surnames. MiGAZIN reported that all applications were written in flawless German, meaning the difference cannot be explained by language skills.
Philipp Lergetporer of TUM, one of the study’s authors, said that discrimination continued even when parents stated that they had higher education, showing that the difference was not solely due to assumptions about the families’ education levels.
“Unequal opportunities can extend to university”
According to Federal Statistical Office data, only 22% of children under the age of 3 with a migrant background attended daycare in 2023, compared with 45% of children without a migrant background. The study found that in districts where discrimination was more pronounced in the experiment, the proportion of children with a migrant background in daycare centers was also lower.

Frauke Peter of DZHW said, “Daycare is the first building block on the path through education. Unequal opportunities in access to daycare can continue to affect children all the way to university.” Henning Hermes of the ifo Institute said daycare directors distribute a limited number of places under intense staff and time pressure, and those with little time may first respond to families they believe will require less effort.
In a survey accompanying the study, about 85% of more than 400 daycare directors said they made the admission decision themselves. Simon Wiederhold of IWH stressed that the legal right to daycare alone does not guarantee equal access, adding that more staff and centralized, transparent application systems could make access fairer.
Sources: ifo Institute, TRT Haber, MiGAZIN. Cover: TRT Haber. Photos: Wikimedia Commons