Germany’s Federal Parliament (Bundestag) approved a comprehensive intelligence reform granting the country’s foreign intelligence service, the BND, and its domestic intelligence agency, the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV), operational powers for the first time. In Friday’s roll-call vote, 309 lawmakers voted in favor, 190 against and 71 abstained.
ARD’s news portal tagesschau reported that the domestic intelligence service, which until now has been largely limited to gathering information and monitoring individuals, will be able under certain conditions to enter homes covertly and take action against explosives and weapons. The service will also be able to disrupt attackers’ infrastructure through cyberattacks, redirect data traffic, delete data stored for an attack and deliberately spread false information in a targeted manner.

BND will be able to shut down servers abroad
The foreign intelligence service BND is also receiving powers to conduct operational interventions. It will be able to disable the servers of state-backed hacker groups abroad, infiltrate foreign IT systems, and alter or delete data. In addition to the long-taboo power of “counterattacks” (hackbacks), limited sabotage aimed at disabling enemy weapons systems will also be possible in certain circumstances.
The power to detain and conduct open searches will remain with the police, while the services will continue to be prohibited from using force against individuals. The membership of the Independent Oversight Council is being increased from six to 12 so that active measures can generally be approved in advance and reviewed afterward in emergencies.
Dobrindt: “They will become real secret services”
Defending the reform, Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt (CSU) said, “Intelligence services are becoming real secret services. We need these measures against enemies of democracy who threaten the country from outside and within.” Saying that Germany is the target of hybrid threats, Dobrindt cited railway sabotage, cyberattacks on hospitals and the attack on Berlin’s electricity infrastructure as examples.

The CDU/CSU-SPD coalition led by Chancellor Friedrich Merz aims through the reform to respond particularly to threats arising from the activities of the intelligence services of Russia, China and Iran, and to reduce dependence on information provided by allied services. In Germany, the powers of the intelligence services and police had previously been separated by clear lines because of the country’s experience during the Nazi era.
The opposition strongly criticized the reform. Alice Weidel, co-chair of the AfD parliamentary group, described the bill as “an attack on the German rule of law.” Clara Bünger, the Left Party’s security spokesperson, argued that the law eroded the principle of separation by granting the intelligence service police-like executive powers. Konstantin von Notz of the Greens said they supported the section concerning the BND but rejected the provisions concerning domestic intelligence. The law will now go to the Federal Council (Bundesrat), while critics are expected to appeal to the Federal Constitutional Court.
Cover: dpa. Photos: Tagesspiegel, tagesschau